• Tools
    • WesPortal
    • Directory
    • Library
    • OneStop
    • WesConnect
    • Calendar
    • WesMaps
    • WFS
    • Moodle
    • EMS
    • GApps
  • About
  • Admission & Financial Aid
  • Academics
  • Campus
  • Athletics
  • Giving
  • Students
  • Alumni
  • Parents
Skip to content Skip to content
Roth on Wesleyan

Voting is Good but Colleges Must Do More

November 5, 2018November 5, 2018 by mroth

Tomorrow is Election Day, and there is a polling place right on the Wesleyan campus. You can find out more about voting in Middletown through our Jewett Center for Community Partnerships here. 

As vital as voting is, I argue in an essay in Inside Higher Education that colleges and universities should do more in this time of peril for freedom of inquiry and expression. I reproduce the piece here. 

 

In a year when inducements to political violence have become normalized at the highest level, colleges and universities must do more than just encourage our students to vote. Free expression, free inquiry and fact-based discussion are essential to higher education, and we must protect them. Diversity and inclusion are core commitments, and so we must oppose those people who cultivate hatred against immigrants or trade in racist stereotypes. And when government officials go beyond obfuscation to outright lying, we must stand up and object. If we don’t, we become complicit in the calamitous corruption infecting our society, and it may not be long before the higher education we offer is no longer worthy of the name.

There may be no more obvious attack on freedom of expression and inquiry than the Trump administration’s regular demonization of the press. Can it be that we have gotten used to campaign rallies at which reporters are described as “disgusting” and the news media is labeled an enemy of the people? Can we abide a president who tells the media to “clean up its act” when it is the target of terrorism? If one objects to this crude stoking of animosity, defenders of the regime will accuse one of “pearl clutching,” as if defending the dignity of journalists were akin to protecting snobbish privileges. When authorities in Saudi Arabia devised their heinous plot to torture and murder a critic of the regime, did they assume their friends in the White House would understand their desire to punish a writer for The Washington Post? Is objecting to Jamal Khashoggi’s murder pearl clutching?

Education is degraded when freedom of inquiry and expression are undermined. We must not be lured, however, into confronting the poisonous partisan dogmatism coming from Washington with similar dogmatism of our own. If we do so, we will merely be preaching to our own choirs. We must instead promote the importance of intellectual diversity in higher education, and we must beware of confusing the critical thinking we value with the ready-made ideological positions held by the majority of professors and students. Colleges and universities must remain open to a variety of intellectual and cultural traditions if they are to speak meaningfully about freedom of inquiry.

We must also not let the administration and its supporters make a mockery of American aspirations toward diversity, equity and inclusion in our institutions and in the larger society. We at colleges and universities have an obligation to preserve those aspirations, for they are essential to the learning environments that we aim to create. The current demonization of immigrants, for example, is meant to instill a sense of fear and insecurity among folks who have lived in this country for many years as productive members of society. Many of our higher education institutions offer support to our undocumented colleagues and friends, and we have pledged not to voluntarily cooperate with federal authorities seeking to intimidate or deport them.

It is true enough that politicians from various points on the political spectrum have long pontificated, stretched the truth, pumped themselves up and distorted inconvenient facts. But over the last two years, we have seen a callous disregard for truth become an ordinary part of public life. Educators must push back on this trend, but not just by digging into our own ideological commitments. People of goodwill, of course, can disagree about issues concerning freedom, the role of the military, the importance of markets and the responsibilities of the state to protect law and order and to help the most vulnerable members of society. No political tradition has a monopoly on the truth. In fact, that’s why intellectual diversity and freedom of inquiry are so vital: we need that diversity and freedom to see the errors of our own ways and to discover more equitable and effective ways of facing the issues before us.

But we must also recognize that our public discourse has entered a new arena of willful misrepresentation. The dismissal of the dangers of human-induced climate change is the most egregious example of the repudiation of science for the sake of political expediency. President Trump routinely denies having said things that he has been recorded saying, and his mantra of complete denial when confronted with the facts is spreading to other politicians. From issues of sexual misconduct to votes against requiring insurance companies to protect those with pre-existing conditions, politicians have learned from this president that lying (loudly and repeatedly) works when the truth is inconvenient. Surely, educational institutions have as a core part of their mandate to expose falsehoods, to gain agreement on the facts of a matter and to leverage those facts for better public policy.

In the summer of 2016, I wrote in these pages to urge those involved in higher education to join forces “to stop the Trumpian calamity.” I spoke out on electoral politics at that time with great reluctance because I do not think it appropriate for university presidents publicly to back one candidate or another. But over the last few years, from Hungary to Brazil, from Italy to the United States, we have seen the intensification of authoritarian, populist political forces around the world. They all demonize a group of outsiders, and they all substitute appeals to myth and violence for inquiry and discussion.

We in higher education must not treat this intensification as a normal dimension of our public life. This political movement is antithetical to learning; it is anathema to research and teaching and to any possibilities for democracy. Our mission in higher education requires us to oppose it. This is not a call for partisan, political indoctrination. It is a call to preserve intellectual diversity and freedom of inquiry by standing up to the poisonous pollution of our public life.

Categories UncategorizedTags Civic Engagement, Election Day, Inside Higher Education, Intellectual Diversity, Vote
Post navigation
Remembering John Maguire (1932-2018)
Wesleyan Volleyball in Elite 8
Michael S. Roth

Michael S. Roth became Wesleyan University's 16th president on July 1, 2007.

We welcome comments from readers, but reserve the right not to publish certain comments, such as those that are anonymous or appear to be spam.

Follow @mroth78 on Twitter

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 5 hours ago

My take on a new book about invisibility "It’s no fun at all, and indeed may be terrifying, to realize that nobody is looking for you." wapo.st/2T76xfN?tid=ss…

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 6 hours ago

On Sadia Shepard & her @Wesleyan_u #documentary film students working in Middletown @wes_engage #WesCreative middletownpress.com/middletown/art… via @Middletownpress

The profile image of holdengraber
Paul Holdengraber 18 hours ago

“By believing passionately in something that still does not exist, we create it. The nonexistent is whatever we have not sufficiently desired.” ~ Franz Kafka thanks to @ilya_poet Retweeted by Michael S Roth

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 1 day ago

Let’s hope so twitter.com/ekleinberg/sta…

The frightening and liberating realization that even the past will change in the future.

— Ethan Kleinberg (@ekleinberg) February 21, 2019
The profile image of wesleyan_u
Wesleyan University 1 day ago

Wesleyan’s Center for Creative Youth (CCY), is a precollege summer residency program in the arts for students ages 14–18. Visit the CCY website to learn more and apply: wesleyan.edu/ccy twitter.com/WesleyanCCY/st… Retweeted by Michael S Roth

The profile image of JohnsPrints
Jasper Johns Prints 3 days ago

#JasperJohns donates 23 signed & numbered limited edition prints to Davison Art Center @wesleyan_u: in honor of #RichardField, author of three catalogue raisonnés of Jasper Johns prints. bit.ly/JasperJohnsPri… Retweeted by Michael S Roth

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 2 days ago

Read ⁦@nytdavidbrooks⁩ “Culture changes when a small group of people, often on the margins of society, find a better way to live, and other people begin to copy them. These Weavers have found a better way to live.” #Interconnection #Weavers ⁦ nytimes.com/2019/02/18/opi…

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 2 days ago

Another @wesleyan_u alumna doing cool things @wes_alumni #WesCreative twitter.com/santigold/stat…

I’ve decided to do a few shows to commemorate the 10 year anniversary of my first record! The #10YearsGolderTour will be a special occasion to perform my whole first album and more! Pre-sales start tomorrow at 10AM local time.

Go to https://t.co/vTp2Xw1PiX to sign up for access pic.twitter.com/0J2CrPkR90

— Santigold (@Santigold) February 19, 2019
The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 3 days ago

Read @parul_sehgal on new book by my friend & @wesleyan_u alum Saidiya Hartman “a rich resurrection of a forgotten history...Her rigor and restraint give her writing its distinctive electricity and tension .” nyti.ms/2Ehwz8b

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 3 days ago

Read ⁦the astute ⁦@DwightGarner⁩ “The portrait of Sessions is of a man for whom merely ordering lunch seems to be above the timberline of his intellect and curiosity.” nyti.ms/2V0KqFl?smid=n…

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 3 days ago

Read @wesleyan_u prof @AmyBloomBooks “Oh, look at me, making money from writing. I didn’t know would happen. Maybe I’ll do a little more of that.” And so I did.” twitter.com/kimberlyburnsp…

“We come up with the show that became State of Mind, develop a pitch, and sell it to NBC. Things are going swimmingly. Then Jeff Zucker becomes head of NBC and famously announces a loss of interest in both women and dialogue. Sure enough…” @amybloombooks https://t.co/WJhimbA8qS

— Kimberly Burns (@kimberlyburnspr) February 19, 2019
The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 3 days ago

Wonderful ⁦@wesleyan_u⁩ event for film folks in LA ⁦@wes_alumni⁩ #WesCreative #CardinalPride

test Twitter Media - Wonderful ⁦@wesleyan_u⁩ event for film folks in LA ⁦@wes_alumni⁩ #WesCreative #CardinalPride https://t.co/XcJ2aL5OzU
test Twitter Media - Wonderful ⁦@wesleyan_u⁩ event for film folks in LA ⁦@wes_alumni⁩ #WesCreative #CardinalPride https://t.co/XcJ2aL5OzU
The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 4 days ago

Read @RusslynnAli "Eliot’s essay is a reminder that education needs to periodically realign itself with the world young people face: As our world changes, so must schools." #WhyLiberalEducationMatters theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/…

The profile image of MelisaOlgun
Melisa Olgun 4 days ago

The @wesleyan_u blood drive is happening now! ❤️ Stop by to donate blood and you’ll get a free t-shirt and cookie from @Weswings (as well as some other snacks!) ❤️ Sign up at redcrossblood.org! Retweeted by Michael S Roth

The profile image of emilynussbaum
Emily Nussbaum 5 days ago

I know these videos are hell to watch, but I don’t want people to forget what this government is responsible for. twitter.com/_SJPeace_/stat… Retweeted by Michael S Roth

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 5 days ago

Read @ValeriaLuiselli “Euphemisms lead us to tolerate the unacceptable. And, eventually, to forget. Against a euphemism, remembrance. In order to not repeat.” #LostChildrenArchive

The profile image of CIS_Wesleyan
College of Integrative Sciences 6 days ago

Applications for the CIS 2019 summer program for Undergraduate Research in the Sciences are due March 8th!! Submit your applications soon! @wesleyan_u Retweeted by Michael S Roth

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 5 days ago

Hope my students, reading #JamesBaldwin this week @wesleyan_u , check these out twitter.com/jennydeluxe/st…

sedat pakay’s intimate portraits of james baldwin (at david zwirner for god made my face) blew me away. to be captured with such love! to be vulnerable enough to *allow* someone capture your love with such love 💫 pic.twitter.com/TvdbJQDdzM

— Jenna Wortham (@jennydeluxe) February 16, 2019
The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 5 days ago

Read ⁦@dwallacewells⁩ on #ClimateChange “We are all living in delusion, unable to really process the news from science that climate change amounts to an all-encompassing threat. Indeed, a threat the size of life itself.” ⁦@nytopinion⁩ nyti.ms/2V2QLA2?smid=n…

The profile image of mroth78
Michael S Roth 6 days ago

Read @ValeriaLuiselli “everything that happened after I took the picture was also inside it, even though no one could see it, except me when I looked at it, and maybe also you, in the future, when you look at it” #LostChildrenArchive

Pages

  • About

Archives

Click here for an RSS feed

Login

  • Log in
© Wesleyan University